skip to Main Content

Don’t Tell Reese’s Peanut Butter Shake

If there’s a celebrity couple more powerful than peanut butter and chocolate, I wouldn’t know who it would be.  (No, really, I wouldn’t.  We only watch My Little Pony here.)  All I know is Reese’s nailed it and we hacked it.  Check out this cool, creamy shake and tell me it doesn’t taste like a million calories!

peanut butter protein shake

Chocolate Peanut Butter Shake You’ll Adore

We hear, “I’d love to lose weight but I just LOOOOOVE chocolate too much.”
Girl, please!  You think WE don’t LOOOOOOOVE chocolate?!  You think chocolate only tastes freaking amazing to you and all the skinny, fit people of the world have a genetic mutation that makes chocolate taste like dish soap?  NO!

I LOOOOOOOVE chocolate too!  And I love peanut butter.  And I love milkshakes.

But you know what else I love?  Sitting down without my pants trying to bite me in half.

So, I make some concessions by giving up the real stuff and instead try to replicate my favorite things in healthier ways so I can have chocolate, and peanut butter, and pants that don’t assault me.

This is one recipe that totally #nailedit in terms of flavor, consistency, AND macros.


This amazing shake has protein powder, PB2 Powder, and milk. That’s it! It’s super simple and after you make it once, you’ll have the recipe memorized.

Why I love PB2 Powder in Shakes

I discovered that the PB2 powder dissolves better in shakes than peanut butter does. So now whenever I want a peanut butter shake of any sort, I grab for the PB2 powder.


Don’t Tell Reese’s Shake

Don’t Tell Reese’s Shake

Yield: 1
Prep Time: 1 minute


  • 1/2 scoop 1st phorm ice cream sandwich protein powder
  • 1/2 scoop 1st phorm chocolate protein powder
  • 8 oz 2% milk
  • 2 Tbs chocolate PB2 powder


  1. Blend until smooth.



Gluten Free:  Yep!

Dairy Free:  You could sub out milk for nut milk and the protein for a non-dairy option.

Vegetarian:  Absolutely!

Nutrition Information:
Serving Size: 1
Amount Per Serving: Total Fat: 9gCarbohydrates: 23gProtein: 35g

Be sure to show me your creations by using our hashtag #getmacroed.  It makes my day to see my recipes in your kitchen and you never know when I might feature one of yours!

All the best,

Affiliate links keep the lights on around here.  By purchasing through some links, you’ll help MacroEd at no additional cost to you.  *High five* and thank you for helping us out!

More Sweet Treats

If you loved this peanut butter shake recipe, here are some more high protein desserts you should try next.

Skip to Recipe
Back To Top